Top Line: How does prospective peer review of contours for head and neck cases influence contouring quality?
The Study: Historically, peer review and even prospective peer review incorporates simultaneous review of contours and treatment plans. In this study, prospective peer review of head and neck contours was implemented at an NCI-designated cancer center. Seven different physicians submitted contours with a median of 5 attending each review session where a median of 9 cases were reviewed. A total of 360 sets of contours were reviewed and graded as green (no change, 89.7%), yellow (minor change, 8.9%), or red (major change, 1.4%). Case load and experience were factors associated with contour change requests. The median number of cases for physicians included in the study was 50, and those with more than the median had half the rate of change requests than those with fewer cases (6.7% v 13.3%). Median clinical experience was 32 months, and those with >12 months experience had significantly fewer change requests than those with less experience (8.3% v 40.9%). Finally, the authors observed changes in the types of change requests over time. After 6 months of the prospective contour review, there were no major changes but there was an increase in minor changes (6.6→ 11.6%).
TBL: In this study from an academic center, over 10% of head and neck contours required modification. Experience and caseload were associated with fewer contour changes. The process of prospective contour review also appeared to reduce the rate of major change requests. | Gogineni, Pract Radiat Oncol 2024
The Study: Historically, peer review and even prospective peer review incorporates simultaneous review of contours and treatment plans. In this study, prospective peer review of head and neck contours was implemented at an NCI-designated cancer center. Seven different physicians submitted contours with a median of 5 attending each review session where a median of 9 cases were reviewed. A total of 360 sets of contours were reviewed and graded as green (no change, 89.7%), yellow (minor change, 8.9%), or red (major change, 1.4%). Case load and experience were factors associated with contour change requests. The median number of cases for physicians included in the study was 50, and those with more than the median had half the rate of change requests than those with fewer cases (6.7% v 13.3%). Median clinical experience was 32 months, and those with >12 months experience had significantly fewer change requests than those with less experience (8.3% v 40.9%). Finally, the authors observed changes in the types of change requests over time. After 6 months of the prospective contour review, there were no major changes but there was an increase in minor changes (6.6→ 11.6%).
TBL: In this study from an academic center, over 10% of head and neck contours required modification. Experience and caseload were associated with fewer contour changes. The process of prospective contour review also appeared to reduce the rate of major change requests. | Gogineni, Pract Radiat Oncol 2024

